The best SUVs under $40,000, according to Consumer Reports

All these Consumer Reports picks deliver all-wheel drive without pushing the price past $40,000

With average new car prices hovering around $50,000 in the latter part of 2025, it can often feel like buying a new car is out of reach, particularly an SUV.

Luckily, Consumer Reports (CR) compiled a list of recommended new SUVs that cost less than $40,000 — even with all-wheel drive. These cars have all been tested by CR’s experts, and some of them even have three rows.

Continue reading to see which made the list, how much they cost, and why they are recommended.

2 / 10

Subaru Forester & Forester Hybrid

Credit: Subaru

Starting at $29,995 for the Forester and $36,595 for the Forester Hybrid, these SUVs emphasize practicality and comfort, returning 29 mpg overall in the standard model and 34 mpg overall in the hybrid. Both offer standard all-wheel drive, excellent outward visibility, a comfortable ride, and a roomy rear seat, with the hybrid adding quieter operation and smoother low-speed response, CR said.

3 / 10

Honda CR-V & CR-V Hybrid

Credit: Honda $HMC

Starting at $30,920 for the standard and $35,630 for the hybrid, the CR-Vs deliver a strong mix of practicality and efficiency, with 26 mpg overall in the gas model and 35 mpg overall in the hybrid. CR said both offer a comfortable ride, responsive handling, a roomy rear seat, easy-to-use controls, and ample cargo space, while the hybrid adds smoother low-speed power and better fuel economy.

4 / 10

Kia Sportage & Sportage Hybrid

Credit: Kia

Starting at $28,690 for the Sportage and $30,290 for the Sportage Hybrid, the Sportage balances space and value with efficiency, returning 25 mpg overall in the gas model and 36 mpg overall in the hybrid. CR said both offer a comfortable ride, responsive handling, and generous rear-seat room, while the hybrid adds smoother acceleration and quieter operation.

5 / 10

Hyundai Tucson & Tucson Hybrid

Credit: Hyundai

The Tucson starts at $29,450, while the Tucson Hybrid begins at $32,450, offering 26 mpg overall for the standard model and 35 mpg overall for the hybrid. CR said both have a steady, comfortable ride, secure handling, a quiet cabin, and ample room for passengers and cargo, with the hybrid delivering stronger low-speed performance.

6 / 10

Mazda CX-50 Hybrid

Credit: Mazda

Starting at $34,750, the CX-50 Hybrid delivers an impressive 37 mpg overall while standing out for its engaging driving dynamics. CR said its sharp steering, controlled handling, supportive seats, and above-average interior quality give it a more upscale feel than many rivals.

7 / 10

Nissan Rogue

Credit: Nissan

Priced from $29,090, the Rogue returns 25 mpg overall and feels solid and well-balanced on the road. CR praised its comfortable ride, nimble handling, easy rear-seat access, and a roomy interior make it a practical compact SUV.

8 / 10

Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid

Credit: Toyota $TM

Starting at $28,995, the Corolla Cross Hybrid leads the group with an excellent 41 mpg overall. CR said it delivers smooth low-speed acceleration, standard all-wheel drive, and a composed ride, making it a standout choice for fuel-conscious buyers.

9 / 10

Ford Escape Hybrid

Bloomberg / Contributor / Getty Images

With a starting price of $30,350, the Escape Hybrid achieves 34 mpg overall and can drive on electric power at low speeds. It combines nimble handling, a steady ride, and a roomy rear seat in a compact, efficient package, according to CR.

10 / 10

Hyundai Santa Fe & Santa Fe Hybrid

Credit: Hyundai

The Santa Fe begins around $35,050 and the Santa Fe Hybrid at $36,400, giving buyers a choice between traditional powertrain and enhanced efficiency. The standard model nets about 24 mpg overall, while the hybrid achieves roughly 34 mpg. CR said both offer a comfortable ride, responsive handling, generous cargo room, and surprisingly usable seating in their compact three-row layouts.