The 6 best small cities to live in America, according to Reader's Digest

Choosing a place to live is about more than weather and jobs. It’s about community, affordability, local amenities, and a sense of belonging. Reader’s Digest’s ranking of the Best small cities to live in the U.S. highlights places that consistently score well across those measures — balancing quality of life, schools, access to services, and neighborhood character.

Small cities — typically with populations under 100,000 — offer something many Americans seek: more space without isolation, local culture without big‑city chaos, and amenities without exorbitant cost. These communities make a case for why more people are reconsidering suburban or small‑city living as remote work and evolving lifestyle priorities change how we think about home.

Here are 6 of the best small cities in the U.S.

Bryce Wendler / Unsplash

Lancaster stands out for its blend of preserved history and contemporary amenities, earning it a spot on Reader’s Digest’s best small cities list.

The city’s walkable downtown brings historic architecture together with vibrant arts, local shops, and diverse restaurants. Cultural institutions and community events anchor daily life, while nearby countryside offers scenic escapes. Lancaster’s housing options range from renovated historic homes to newer developments, making it adaptable for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

The city’s size and layout foster a strong community feel without sacrificing access to healthcare, education, and regional job markets. Its blend of old‑town charisma and contemporary convenience makes Lancaster a compelling choice for anyone seeking balance in small‑city living.

Steven Val Elk / Unsplash

Carmel is widely recognized for its high quality of life, strong public services, and community design, placing it among Reader’s Digest’s best small cities to live in.

The city’s efficient layout includes extensive parks, well‑planned neighborhoods, and cultural venues. Carmel’s commitment to public art, pathways, and community events reinforces its reputation as an inviting place to live. Housing options are varied, and local schools consistently perform well, adding to its appeal for families.

Regular community gatherings, bikeable streets, and a thriving local economy make this Indiana city feel bigger in opportunity but smaller in stress. Carmel’s blend of suburban comfort with cultural vibrancy sets it apart in small‑city rankings.

Manoj Balotia / Unsplash

Fair Lawn appears on Reader’s Digest’s list as a small city that delivers both proximity to larger metro areas and strong local community life.

Situated within reach of New York City’s job markets, Fair Lawn maintains its own identity with quiet neighborhoods, local parks, and community events. The city’s infrastructure supports residents with solid schools, transit options, and plenty of small‑business amenities.

For those seeking a balance of suburban peace and urban connectivity, Fair Lawn offers the best of both worlds without losing the charm that smaller cities provide.

Yifan Gu / Unsplash

Lexington earns its place on the Reader’s Digest best small cities list with deep historical roots and a strong community culture.

Known for its Revolutionary War heritage, this Massachusetts city combines tree‑lined streets and preserved sites with thriving local commerce. Community events, highly rated schools, and walkable neighborhoods make it particularly attractive for families.

Its location near Boston adds professional opportunities while preserving a smaller‑city vibrancy that feels distinct from big‑city hustle. Residents benefit from cultural institutions and regional transit without sacrificing local identity.

Alex Reynolds / Unsplash

Brentwood appears on Reader’s Digest’s best small cities lineup for its strong local amenities and quality of life.

Families and professionals alike appreciate Brentwood’s mix of good schools, parks, and community services. Its residential neighborhoods are complemented by local shops and dining, creating a comfortable pace of life. The city’s growth reflects broader interest in affordable, amenity‑rich living outside major urban centers.

Brentwood maintains small‑city intimacy while offering the services people expect in larger places, making it a compelling choice for long‑term residents.

Zoshua Colah / Unsplash

Melrose rounds out Reader’s Digest’s selection with its blend of community engagement and proximity to urban attractions.

This Massachusetts city features quiet residential streets, local parks, and a downtown area with small businesses and eateries. Melrose’s location near Boston makes it ideal for commuters who want access to big‑city jobs but prefer small‑city living.

Residents enjoy regular community events, strong local schools, and a neighborhood feel that fosters connection and convenience. Melrose proves that small cities can be rich in both life and proximity to opportunity.