Finger Lakes named AirDNA's best budget-friendly short-term rental market of 2026

The appeal of owning a short-term rental is easy to understand. A well-chosen property can generate income, appreciate in value, and serve as a personal retreat. But most of the conversation focuses on high-profile markets where property prices are anything but accessible. Beach towns in the Carolinas, mountain getaways in Colorado, and coastal communities in California capture the imagination but can require deep pockets just to get through the front door.

Entry price is only the starting line. Total cost of ownership — including property taxes, insurance, maintenance, furnishing, and cash reserves — can add up fast. Investors working with $250,000 or less have no choice but to target affordable markets. But that is not necessarily a bad thing.

Yield measures how much income a property can generate relative to what it costs to buy. A market with modest nightly rates but a $175,000 average home price can outperform a flashier destination on cash flow. Demand durability — the ability to attract guests across multiple seasons and motivations, not just a few peak weekends — reduces vacancy risk for investors who can't afford to carry an empty property for months at a time. Smaller markets that rely on specific industries can sustain the necessary demand.

The type of guest experience also matters. Travelers $TRV booking homes in the $100,000 to $250,000 range don't expect luxury finishes. They look for convenient access, comfortable spaces, and straightforward amenities. Investors who understand their reality and avoid competing with premium properties are better positioned to keep up occupancy and build consistent returns.

AirDNA analyzed U.S. short-term rental markets and ranked them by yield, filtering only for places where the average price of for-sale properties falls between $100,000 and $250,000. The results uncover five pockets where the combination of home prices, demand drivers, and income potential makes a compelling case for budget-conscious investors.

Matt Champlin / Getty Images

Average home price: $184,000 | Yield: 19.6%

Upstate New York doesn't get much credit as a short-term rental market, but the Finger Lakes region challenges that assumption. The area draws guests year-round for lake activities, wine country tours, fall foliage trips, and winter getaways — demand that spreads bookings across seasons rather than a few summer weeks. The average length of stay approaches four days, which reduces the turnover burden for hosts who self-manage cleaning and operations.

What makes the economics stand out is the disconnect between the destination's national profile and its property prices. The Finger Lakes is a well-known leisure market, yet the average home price across its 23 submarkets — which include towns such as Lansing, Dundee, Dresden, and Trumansburg — sits at approximately $184,000. Average annual revenue potential reaches nearly $36,000, producing an average yield of 19.6%. Peak season occupancy climbs to around 70% on average between June and August.

Regulatory conditions vary across the region. The City of Canandaigua allows short-term rentals through a Special Use Permit process, while the City of Ithaca only authorizes primary residences. Investors should review local ordinances for any specific submarket before purchasing.

Denis Tangney Jr. / Getty Images

Average home price: $180,000 | Yield: 19.6%

South Bend's headline 19.6% average yield owes a lot to the University of Notre Dame's football Saturdays, graduations weekends, and alumni events. But it isn't the only draw in town. Regional leisure travel, family visits, and weekend trips fill shoulder periods throughout the year.. The Studebaker National Museum, revitalized downtown dining scene, and St. Joseph River add variety to the visitor mix and reduce the probability of going vacant during quieter stretches.

While South Bend's high-demand events push average daily rates well above baseline, the mix of attractions fills rooms across 52 weeks, not just eight home game weekends. The area also includes the surrounding submarkets of Elkhart and Mishawaka, and home prices vary based on proximity to downtown and the university. 

The average home price sits just under $180,000, which is low enough to keep carrying costs manageable. Average annual revenue potential tops out at just over $35,000. On the regulatory side, South Bend requires city licensing for short-term rentals, though the specifics on zoning restrictions and operational limits remain unclear.

Dee Liu / Getty Images

Average home price: $182,232 | Yield: 19.4%

Rochester's short-term rental profile is built on layered, repeatable demand rather than a single attraction or season. Cultural institutions, including The Strong National Museum of Play and the George Eastman Museum, drive family and leisure travel year-round. Lake Ontario and the surrounding parks bring in warm-weather visitors, while Rochester's position as a gateway to the Finger Lakes widens the visitor funnel for guests on longer regional itineraries. University and medical travel adds additional midweek demand that most purely leisure-oriented markets lack.

One practical advantage for operators is the average length of stay, which approaches six days here. Longer stays reduce turnover frequency, which lowers cleaning costs and operational complexity for hosts who self-manage. That dynamic helps protect margins in a market where nightly rates don't command premium prices.

The market rewards disciplined investors. The average home price in Rochester is $182,232, which keeps financing costs and breakeven thresholds manageable. Average annual revenue potential is just over $35,000, equating to an average yield of 19.4%. The regulatory environment warrants close attention: Monroe County has not implemented a state-mandated short-term rental registry, but the City of Rochester is exploring zoning changes that could restrict STRs in low-density residential areas.

Joe Daniel Price / Getty Images

Average home price: $175,549 | Yield: 19.3%

At $175,549, St. Louis has the lowest average home price on this list. But price alone doesn't tell the full story. A year-round mix of sports, concerts, conventions, and cultural tourism backs the city's short-term rental, filling calendars well beyond peak weekends. Gateway Arch National Park, Forest Park, the City Museum, and the Missouri Botanical Garden draw a wide range of travelers, and the events calendar generates the kind of midweek demand that purely leisure-oriented markets rarely produce.

Investors who can't afford extended vacancy need a consistent market, and St. Louis delivers through diversified demand. Average annual revenue potential is $33,881, reflecting an average yield of 19.3% across 43 submarkets.

The city technically requires a permit for short-term rentals, but a court order issued in April 2025 suspended enforcement, creating confusion for would-be investors. Investors should monitor city guidance and build conservative assumptions into their underwriting until the situation resolves.

Wiltser / Getty Images

Average home price: $185,840 | Yield: 19.2%

West Coastal Michigan stretches across 17 submarkets along the Lake Michigan shoreline, from the Indiana border up through Manistee. Wide sandy beaches, walkable downtowns, marinas, and waterfront parks anchor a summer season that generates strong demand from Chicago-area day-trippers, weekenders, and families on longer vacation stays. Muskegon, Holland, Grand Haven, and Benton Harbor each have distinct identities that support repeat visits.

Seasonal events create predictable peak periods that help investors forecast demand with some confidence. Holland's Tulip Time Festival, Grand Haven's musical fountain and beach scene, Muskegon's outdoor recreation and cultural programming, and Manistee's historic character all contribute to shoulder-season bookings that extend the earning window beyond peak summer weeks. 

The financials are competitive with the other markets on this list. The average home price across the region is approximately $185,840. Average annual revenue potential is roughly $35,681, translating to an average yield of 19.2%. Regulatory requirements are set at the city or town level, so conditions vary. Muskegon, for example, requires a short-term rental license to operate, with escalating penalties and potential license annulment for violations.